Alphabetical Menu
Chronological Menu

Reviews for December 25th, 2023

Documentary/Experimental Films




 

      Based on the book Atlas of an Occupied City, Amsterdam 1940-1945 by Bianca Stigter, Occupied City is an ambitious and provocative, but ultimately exhausting and tedious documentary about the Nazi occupation of Amsterdam and Amsterdam's response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Director Steve McQueen bites off more than he could chew as he combines two different documentary subjects in one. As the narrator, Melanie Hyams, describes how each location shown was significant during the Holocaust in World War II, there are also images from the recent pandemic showing protests, closed stores and draconian police. It's a lot to take in, so it's easy for the audience to feel overwhelmed. More often than not, the images and the words are in stark contrast with each other, but the main issue is that there's just too much going on all at once to process. Also, the narration sounds very monotonous and emotionless which gives the sensation that you're watching a dry academic film in history class. Occupied City makes its points and then repeats them over and over in different ways. A truly great documentary finds the right balance between entertaining the audience and provoking them emotionally as well as intellectually. Unfortunately, Occupied City fails to find that balance. At an overlong 4 hours and 22 minutes (including a 15-minute intermission), it opens at Film Forum via A24.


The Crime is Mine

Directed by François Ozon




      Madeleine (Nadia Tereszkiewicz), an aspiring actress lives with her best friend, Pauline (Rebecca Marder), a lawyer, while struggling to make ends meet. When she gets accused of murdering a film producer, Monrferrand (Jean-Christophe Bouvet), she and Pauline come up with a scheme to become rich and famous while she stands trial for the murder, but their scheme doesn't go as planned.

       Based on the play Mon Crime by Georges Berr and Louis Verneuil, the screenplay by François Ozon brims with witty humor, campiness and many surprises.  Madeleine has a romantic love interest, André (Édouard Sulpice) with a wealthy father (André Dussollier), but that subplot doesn't distract from the comedic elements and leads to even more screwball comedy in the third act. The plot synopsis above merely summarizes the first thirty minutes. What happens afterwards won't be spoiled here, though, but it's worth mentioning that the plot, set in 1935, gets increasingly twisty and zany. The dialogue sparkles with wit and tongue-and-cheek humor. There's a courtroom scene that rivals the funny scenes in Adam's Rib and My Cousin Vinny.  Each character is amusingly over-the-top including the judge, Gustave Rabusset (Fabrice Luchini), and, especially, Odette (Isabelle Huppert). With a less talented filmmaker, The Crime is Mine could've easily turned into a tonal mess, but Ozon, fortunately, has a wonderful command of tone that's reminiscent of classic screwball comedies from the Golden Age of American Cinema and the French comedies of Francis Veber's ike The Dinner Game.

       The ensemble cast are all terrific from the lead actresses, Nadia Tereszkiewicz and Rebecca Marder, to the actors and actresses in supporting roles like André Dussollier, Isabelle Huppert, Fabrice Luchini and Édouard Sulpice. They each get the chance to shine. Isabelle Huppert is clearly having a lot of fun as Odette and has impeccable comedic timing. The way that she makes her entrance in the film is very funny and memorable. It's refreshing to see her in a comedy for change. The pace moves briskly enough so that there's not a dull moment. Moreover, the costume designs are quite impressive along with the hair and makeup design. At a running time of 1 hour and 42 minutes, The Crime is Mine is a hilarious, witty and sparkling comedy. It's a wildly entertaining and crowd-pleasing delight.
  

Number of times I checked my watch: 1
Released by Music Box Films.
Opens at Quad Cinema.

Ferrari

Directed by Michael Mann




      Enzo Ferrari (Adam Driver) and his wife, Laura (Penelope Cruz), struggle to keep their Ferrari manufacturing company afloat as it nears bankruptcy. He tries to boost the sales of his business by having his drivers in compete a 1,000-mile race called Mille Miglia, but he also has to deal with the consequences of his wife finding out that he has an illegitimate son, Piero, with another lover, Lina Lardi (Shailene Woodley).

      Based on the book Enzo Ferrari: The Man, the Cars, the Races by Brock Yates, the screenplay by Troy Kennedy Martin is a snapshot of Enzo Ferrari during the summer of 1957. To call it a biopic would be inaccurate because it doesn't chart Ferrari's life from childhood to adulthood. Much like the recent Golda, Ferrari is a character study of someone who's under a lot of pressure to save their career and reputation. Enzo comes across as a flawed husband who has no shame in cheating on his wife, Laura, and keeping the secret of his illegitimate son from her until she discovers that herself. Laura is a more compelling character than Enzo. Fortunately, the screenplay focuses its attention on her enough to understand the emotional pain that she's going through. She's a strong woman who doesn't put up with being mistreated, and it says a lot about her that she handles the finances of Ferrari's business. He's not very reliable, though, for many reasons including the fact that he didn't sign a future dated check that he gives to Laura. The weaker moments of the film are the scenes where Enzo spends time with Lina and his son. Those scenes feel contrived and not as engrossing as the rest of the film. When Ferrari gets to the action sequences during the Mille Miglia race, it turns into a thrilling and exhilarating spectacle without being exhausting or tedious. Screenwriter Troy Kennedy Martin finds the Spectacle within the film's humanity off the race tracks, though, as it engages the audience emotionally by focusing on the evolving dynamics of the relationship between Enzo and Laura.

      Adam Driver gives a terrific performance as Enzo Ferrari. He's very cast and brings plenty of charisma and emotional depth to his role. The highlight, though, is Penelope Cruz who's radiant with her many emotionally resonating scenes. Shailene Woodley, unfortunately, feels somewhat miscast here, and her Italian accent isn't very convincing. Sarah Gadon, Patrick Dempsy and Jack O'Connell make the most out of their supporting roles, but they're wasted here. Moreover, there's some choppy editing, i.e. between the scene where Laura goes to the bank and the scene that follows it. The cut between the two scenes is too abrupt. Keep in mind that one of the racing scenes shows an accident with almost as much gore that you'd expect to find in a horror film. The gore leaves nothing to the imagination and ends up just shocking and disgusting the audience which makes it feel out of place. That said, the cinematography, music score and sound design are superb, just as you would expect from a Michael Mann film. Although, to be fair, Ferrari doesn't make use of its visual style to create a palpable atmosphere like in Mann's past films, i.e. Heat and The Insider. At a running time of 2 hours and 10 minutes, Ferrari is captivating, heartfelt and exhilarating with stellar performances by Adam Driver and Penelope Cruz.
  

Number of times I checked my watch: 2
Released by NEON.
Opens nationwide.

The Teachers Lounge

Directed by Ilker Çatak


       Carla Nowak (Leonie Benesch) works as a math and gym teacher at a German middle school. After a series of thefts that includes cash, her students get searched and one of them, Ali (Can Rodenbostel), who's Turkish, gets caught with cash in his backpack. He insists that he's innocent and has a logical explanation for the cash, so Carla decides to take the investigation into her own hands. She suspects that the school's secretary, Mrs. Kuhn (Eva Löbau), could be the thief.

     

        Carla has good intentions and seems like a decent person. She cares about her students and wants to do what's right by finding out the truth behind who actually stole the cash. The lengths in which she goes to investigate the theft leads to moral ambiguity because she does cross a line that she doesn't have the right to cross. She's also quick to point her finger at Mrs. Kuhn as the thief based on circumstantial evidence. Her flaws, though, along with the moral ambiguity, are large part of what makes her such a compelling character. There's more to her than meets the eye. The filmmakers do a very effective job of incorporating exposition and building tension gradually while maintaining suspense. There are also a few surprises along the way which won't be spoiled here, but it's worth mentioning that there's just enough room for interpretation because Çatak and Duncker trust the audience's intelligence as well as their imagination. The screenplay by writer/director Ilker Çatak and co-writer Johannes Duncker takes a premise that sounds simple, lean and straightforward and turns into a complex, intriguing and profound exploration of human nature, truth, justice and, above all, democracy. It avoids becoming heavy-handed, contrived, convoluted and meanderings, so by maintaining focus and grounding the narrative in authenticity, it becomes an immersive, intense roller coaster ride of emotions while keeping you at the edge of your seat from start to finish.

      Leonie Benesch gives a raw, bravura and mesmerizing performance. She tackles the emotional complexities of her role as Carla very convincingly. The supporting cast including child actors are just as superb. The music score helps to add to the dramatic tension without being intrusive or overbearing. It's similar to the nerve-wracking music score in Shiva Baby and Uncut Gems.  The cinematography and the use of the 4:3 aspect ratio also contributes to the film's intensity while making it feel cinematic. In other words, The Teachers' Lounge finds just the right balance between Truth and Spectacle while also finding plenty Spectacle within its Truths, a.k.a. its humanity. At a running time of 1 hour and 34 minutes, The Teachers' Lounge is a spellbinding, taut and provocative psychological thriller. 
  

Number of times I checked my watch: 1
Released by Sony Pictures Classics.
Opens at Angelika Film Center.